Home Shield Coating vs Tex Coat Paint vs Rhino Shield Paint Warranty Comparison

Home Shield Coating® on Cedar Siding House in McHenry, Illinois
Home Shield Coating® Before & After On Cedar House

New Lifetime Paint Products at Home Shows

When you visit a home show, you’ll often see many new wall-coating companies with catchy names like Gorilla Coat, Turtle Coat, Armadillo Coat, Dog Coat, Shark Coat, and Flying Squirrel Coat. These companies usually don’t last long, often surviving only a year or two if they’re lucky. They introduce mysterious products that leave customers wondering what they’ll get. Despite their promises of lifetime transferable warranties, their lack of experience and short business history make it hard for them to back up these claims.

What to Look for When Hiring a Lifetime Paint Company?

  • Physical Business Location: Make sure they have an office you can visit.
  • BBB Membership: Check if they’re members of the Better Business Bureau.
  • Local Business License: Verify they have a local business license.
  • Insurance: Confirm they have insurance.
  • Product Data Sheet: Ask for the product data sheet.
  • Product Verification: Ensure the product you’re purchasing is on-site by checking the labels.
  • Research: Google the company name followed by “complaints” or “lawsuits” and look beyond the first page of results.

Avoid companies operating out of an apartment or home. A legitimate coating business should have a warehouse for storing, tinting, and preparing coatings before sending them to job sites. If a company relies on local big box stores or paint shops, they’re probably not using a specialized coating system for your property.

The Reality of Bargain Lifetime Paint Companies

Most discount coating companies at home shows or in local coupon books are just selling standard acrylic paint. Modern paints are usually designed to last 3 to 5 years because manufacturers want repeat business. Just because you call a paint a coating it doesn’t make it last longer. You can call your Prius a Porsche, but it won’t go any faster. You can’t take a person working out of the back of their truck too serious when they tell you about their lifetime warranty.

Original Home Shield Coating® Label and Container Circa 1999.
Home Shield Coating® Putting Smiles On Faces Since 1999

Are Lifetime Paints Worth the Money?

The value of permanent coatings depends on the contractor and the product they use. Important factors include:

  • Preparation: Proper preparation is key.
  • Proven Experience: Choose companies with a proven track record.
  • Product History: Make sure the product has a successful history.

Be careful about being one of the first projects the new local “Armadillo Coating” dealer does. 

What’s the Difference Between Home Shield Coating®, Tex Cote Paint, Rhino Shield Paint?

Everything! -different products and different warranties. Let’s compare our warranty to Tex-Cote and Rhino Shield. We have nothing to hide and are happy to explain our warranty and our competitors’ warranties as well. We’re so confident in our experience, product, application methods, and warranty. That we encourage you to schedule an estimate with both Tex-Cote and Rhino Shield as well.

Home Shield Coating’s Warranty Explained

Home Shield Coating® has been the premier permanent wall coating company in the industry since 1999. We started coating homes in Chicago, IL where our product has been put up against the harshest of weather conditions. Our coating is a two-part, three-coat permanent coating system that includes:

  • Part A: Bonding Agent Primer (Pink Primer)
  • Part B: HSC Topcoat, available in any color of your choice

Home Shield Coating® offers a 30-Year Combined Warranty:

  • First 10 Years: Covers Labor and Material
  • After 10 Years: 20-Year Material Warranty

Home Shield Coating® is the only company in the industry offering a 10-Year Labor Guarantee, showing our commitment to customer satisfaction and confidence in our products. We are the premier exterior wall coating company in the industry. We’re the company you hire when you want it done right the first 

Warranty Comparison Home Shield Coating vs Rhino Shield vs Tex Cote
Tex Cote vs Rhino Shield vs Home Shield Coating Warranty Graph

Tex-Cote’s Lifetime Warranty What It Really Means

Tex-Cote is the oldest coating company in the country, selling wall coatings since 1961. They sell a product called Coolwall through their dealer network and offer a lifetime warranty on the product but exclude labor. Tex-Cote is upfront about this labor exclusion. The fact that they exclude labor doesn’t mean their coating doesn’t work or is inferior. Tex-Cote has been around for a long time and has contributed a lot to the coating industry. With Tex-Cote, it’s all about the dealer’s expertise. If you have a local dealer who knows what they’re doing, you can expect a long-lasting exterior finish that will look great for decades. Avoid dealers with less than five years of experience.

Why Tex Cote Dealer Experience Is Important

If you hire a new coating dealer with no experience, expect poor results. The new local Tex-Cote dealer AWA Coatings in Orlando, FL, liked our before and after pictures so much that he used one of them on his website, he just decided to clone our entire website design. He claims to be a veteran and to have been in business since 1961. Yet he doesn’t have any before and after pictures of work he’s done since 1961. We have a copy of the letter our attorney sent him along with screen shots of his cloned website showing the cedar house we did in Milwaukee, Wisconsin on his website in Orlando, FL. If anyone wants to see them—call our office. Unfortunately, not all veterans are honorable; this dealer is off to a bad start we would never claim someone else’s work as our own. 

Tex Cote Labor Excluded Warranty
Tex Cote's Paint Sample Warranty

Rhino Shield’s 25 Year Warranty What It Really Means

Rhino Shield started in Indiana and was incorporated in Florida in December 2001. They sell and distribute Rhino Shield through their dealer network. Rhino Shield offers a 25-year warranty that covers labor for one year. Rhino Shield has upset quite a few customers because they weren’t aware of the 1-Year Labor Warranty. One customer contacted the local news in Orlando, FL, after the local Rhino Shield dealer went out of business.

Rhino Shield’s One Year Labor Warranty

According to an investigative news report, the responsibility to cover warranty claims falls on the local dealers, who may no longer be in business. New dealers aren’t responsible for previous dealers’ warranty claims. The new dealer can start fresh, turning problems into new income opportunities. Unfortunately, this has happened in several markets. The Rhino Shield office in Milwaukee, WI, has had three different owners. It’s been interesting to watch this unfold multiple times. New dealers offer potential customers a “whatever they need to hear to write a check” warrantee, but previous customers are stuck with a 1-Year Labor Warranty. The new dealer soon finds themselves losing money and end up going out of business.

Rhino Shield’s Unhappy Customers 

Customers in Wisconsin and other states are upset to the point they were calling for a class action lawsuit. They don’t want to hear the same old “New Owners” different warranty story. They want their homes repaired and their calls answered. This bad publicity has hurt the coating business in several markets. We’ve had to make crystal clear to people that the only similarity between Home Shield Coating and Rhino Shield is the word “SHIELD.”

Rhino Shield 1 Year Labor Warranty
Rhino Shield Paint Sample Warranty

Disclaimer: This blog is for warranty comparison purposes only. We encourage consumers to always get three estimates. We actually prefer selling in a competitive environment. Looking into exterior permanent wall coatings can be worthwhile if you ask the right questions and hire the correct company. If you plan on owning a property for more than three years, investing in a high-quality coating system installed by a reputable company makes sense and will provide a great return on investment. To learn more about exterior wall coatings, schedule an estimate today!

Home Shield Coating® is a commercial grade permanent exterior wall coating system. Pictured here is the bonding agent (Pink Primer) and Top Coat.
Home Shield Coating® Proprietary Permanent Coating

                                      Common Questions & Answers

If a coating contractor is part of a dealer network and goes out of business, who backs the warranty?

Short answer: not corporate. There’s a real possibility that your warranty could be void if the dealer closes or changes owners.

Is fading covered by exterior wall coating warranty?

No. Most coatings are fade-resistant, not fade-proof.

How much more expensive is coating vs paint?

This is tough to answer because paint prices vary widely. The best way to find out is to request an estimate below. 

Do I have to keep the same color forever?

No, changing colors is simple and affordable.

Is there some sort of R-Value gained by the ceramics in wall coatings?

No, while ceramics have been known to reduce exterior wall temperatures. It’s impossible to determine any sort of R-Value since this will depend on what is in between the walls and the year the property was build and what type of insulation was used during construction. 

Conclusion: Exterior Permanent Wall Coatings can be worth it if you ask the right questions and hire the right company. If you plan on living in a property for three years or more, exploring a long lasting exterior wall coating makes sense and will save you money. 

Recent Articles

Stucco House With Cracks Repaired

Stucco Crack Repairs 

Stucco Cracks Repaired by Home Shield Coating® of Florida. Are Stucco Cracks Serious? Yes, stucco cracks can seriously compromise your…

Continue Reading
Home Shield Coating® discussing the importance of waterproofing stucco.

Waterproofing Stucco Walls

Is Stucco Waterproof? No, living in Florida means becoming intimately familiar with unpredictable weather and annual hurricane seasons. For property…

Continue Reading
Home Shield Coating® on Aluminum Siding Before & After.

Painting Aluminum Siding

Home Shield Coating® On Aluminum Siding https://youtu.be/LKSSp91ugmo Home Shield Coating®: The Permanent Solution for Refinishing Aluminum Siding Considering a refresh…

Continue Reading